Category Archives: History

Bella Ciao: A travelling anthem of resistance

This article was originally written by Ananyaย Wilson-Bhattacharya and published by The New Arab.


Ananya Wilson-Bhattacharya explains why the revolutionary protest song, โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ continues to play a role in global struggles today, and how it has served anti-government Gota Go Gama protests in Sri Lanka which forced the president to resign.

Earlier this summer, a video from the Sri Lankan โ€˜Gota Go Gamaโ€™ protests circulated online: the president Gotabaya Rajapaksa had finally resigned, and protestors were singing a Singhala version of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™, the popular Italian song which was used in the Partisan anti-fascist resistance movement of the 1930s and 1940s. While the military violence and attacks on protestors in Sri Lanka continue, this was a clear moment of victorious celebration in the ongoing movement against the authoritarian regime.

The song – which details the singerโ€™s awareness of their imminent death at the hands of the โ€˜invaderโ€™ and desire to die as a โ€˜partisanโ€™ or freedom fighter – has been adapted by various anti-fascist movements globally prior to its use in the Gota Go Gama protests. In fact, the protests are part of a wider trend of anti-authoritarian resistance movements across South Asia in recent years, several of which have been characterised by new versions of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ in different languages.

”This cyclical, continual reproduction of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ across starkly contrasting yet uncannily similar contexts of protest is ultimately testament to the unifying power of protest music, as reproduced across time and space, in illuminating connections between struggles across decades, centuries and continents against a backdrop of evolving forms of capitalism.”

Symbolic image of the people’s revolution based on the series “La casa de papel”. Image by AbarcaVasti, licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license.

Anthem of struggle

Certain features of the song have held throughout its reproduction across different contexts: its undeniable catchiness, and its clear theme of political resistance, despite drastic shifts in its lyrics. The song has even found its way beyond the realm of resistance movements into mainstream television, famously featuring in the hit Spanish crime drama Money Heist.

A Hindi adaptation of the song was released around the time of the mass protests against the fascistic Citizenship Amendment Act, or CAA, introduced in India in 2019. Broadly, the CAA aims to deny Indian citizenship to (Indian) Muslims; it is widely perceived as a step towards ethnic cleansing, indicating the current escalation of Modiโ€™s Hindu supremacist regime into full-blown fascism.

Following the popularity of โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™, the songwriter, Poojan Sahil, subsequently penned a Punjabi version retaining the same melody with new lyrics, also entitled โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ (โ€˜Go Backโ€™), for the large-scale Indian farmersโ€™ movement protesting new anti-farmer legislation introduced by Modiโ€™s government in 2020. These farm laws, which received global coverage and were largely retracted in Autumn 2021 following the year-long mass protests, were set to adversely affect poor farmers, and are widely seen to represent the ongoing corporate takeover of agriculture in India.

Both versions of โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ have a similar theme lyrically to โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ โ€“ although, as Sahil clarified, the songs are not translations. The Hindi version alludes to the fascism of the Indian government through the repeated line โ€˜go away, o you tyrantโ€™, explicitly locating the singer within the resistance movement, and the song as an unmistakably anti-fascist anthem.

โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ (across both versions) also moves away from the somewhat personal lyrics of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™, which uses the singular pronoun โ€˜Iโ€™ throughout (in contrast to โ€˜weโ€™ in โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™) and captures the fear invoked by the rise of fascism through the line โ€˜I feel death approachingโ€™. By contrast, the lyrics of the Punjabi โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ discuss the movement against the Indian government and the major companies which are profiting from the farm laws. Both versions of โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ are thus references to the context of the original song which take its anti-fascist commentary a step further, situating themselves within a specific anti-fascist protest movement.

By pairing the original melody with a sparse acoustic guitar, these versions both highlight the timeless catchiness of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ as well as showing its versatility in lending itself to diverse musical styles โ€“ and languages – of different eras and locations. The case of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™/ โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ illustrates Walter Benjaminโ€™s suggestion that reproduction allows the work of art โ€˜to come closer to whatever situation the person apprehending it is inโ€™, and thereby โ€˜actualises what is reproducedโ€™.

Interestingly, the anti-fascist or partisan โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ is not, in fact, the original version -despite being the best-known – but is adapted from the โ€˜mondineโ€™ version, which originated as a folk song sung by mainly women paddy workers (mondine) in Northern Italy in the late 19th century in protest against harsh working conditions. This agrarian context is evoked โ€“ intentionally on Sahilโ€™s part – by the Punjabi version of โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ centred on the farmersโ€™ movement, which includes the lyrics โ€˜each grain of soil sings in chorusโ€™.

Taking on the tyrant

Whilst the anti-fascist version of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ focused on resistance against โ€˜the invaderโ€™ as opposed to โ€˜the bossโ€™ of the original version, the Punjabi โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™ evokes a new kind of invader โ€“ or โ€˜tyrantโ€™ โ€“ the Indian government and the companies taking over Indian agriculture, which are being urged to โ€˜go backโ€™ by agricultural workers. This version recalls the voice and perspective of the original song, in a new political, geographical, and temporal context.

Indeed, this evoking of the original version also underlines the concentration of agricultural workers in the Global South and their relative decline in the Global North during the 20th century.

Having originally been centred on workersโ€™ experiences, and subsequently been reproduced and adapted in various contexts of anti-fascism, โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ is once again being used to shed light on (agricultural) workersโ€™ struggles through the Punjabi โ€˜Wapas Jaoโ€™.

Through both versions, meanwhile, Sahil arguably utilises the fame of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ as an anthem of resistance against the widely-known rise of fascism in 1930s Europe, referencing the song through reproduction as a way to emphasise the gravity of the current situation in India through implicit comparison.

This cyclical, continual reproduction of โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ across starkly contrasting yet uncannily similar contexts of protest is ultimately testament to the unifying power of protest music, as reproduced across time and space, in illuminating connections between struggles across decades, centuries and continents against a backdrop of evolving forms of capitalism.

The Gota Go Gama protestors singing โ€˜Bella Ciaoโ€™ sends an affirmingly hopeful message โ€“ that the movement recognises itself as situated within a history of peopleโ€™s struggles all sharing the same determination for change, from the anti-fascists in Italy to the farmers in India and everything in between and beyond.

Ananya Wilson-Bhattacharya is a writer, activist and co-editor of Red Pepper magazine, interested in arts and culture and social movements.

Follow her on Twitter: @AnanyaWilson

Cover photo by AntanO. Image licensed under theย Creative Commonsย Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 Internationalย license.


The Kuti Clan Protesting Through Music, And Other Nigerians Who Sang Against Apartheid

Femi and Seun Kuti, have kept Fแบนlรก’s protest music alive.

Orlando Juliasโ€™ band (Nigeria). Image by Steve Terrell, September 26, 2015 (CC BY 2.0)

This article was written by Nwachukwu Egbunike and originally published by Global Voices on 31st of March 2022.


Nigerian musicians have been very vocal about social injustice in the country. The term protest music as a genre, which gained popular cultural validity in the 1970s, has continued to date. These songs fought military dictatorship, apartheid in South Africa, and police brutality, as part of the youth-led #EndSARS protests.

The father of Nigerian protest music

An artistic representation of Fแบนlรก Anรญkรบlรกpรฒ Kรบtรฌ. Image by Danny PiG uploaded to Flickr on September 11, 2012. (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Fแบนlรก Anรญkรบlรกpรฒ Kรบtรฌ (1938โ€“1997), the father of protest music in Nigeria, employed his distinctive Afrobeat genre with lyrics that were replete with โ€œsarcastic humor, rebellion against authority, and political consciousnessโ€ as a means of fighting social injustice, notes Titilayo Remilekun Osuagwu, a culture scholar in Nigeriaโ€™s University of Port Harcourt.

Fแบนlรกโ€™s genius lied in his conceptualization of the root causes of oppression. That’s why his music has remained โ€” to date โ€” a powerful tool in the โ€œsustenance of ongoing protests,โ€ asserts Olukayode โ€˜Segun Eesuola, a political science scholar in Nigeria’s University of Lagos. In the course of his over three decades-long musical career, he heightened the political consciousness of generations of Nigerian citizens. However, this attracted brutal visitations from security agents of successive Nigerian governments.

Understandably, most of Fแบนlรกโ€˜s music was directed against the excesses of successive military governments in the country. Nigeria was under military dictatorship for 29 years (from 1966 to 1979 and 1983 to 1999).

At the time of his death in 1997, Fแบนlรก fiery musical body of work had earned him a place โ€œin global consciousness as a quintessential โ€˜political musician,โ€™โ€ asserts Tejumola Olaniyan, professor of African Languages and Literature at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in his seminal book โ€œArrest the Music! Fela & His rebel art and politics.โ€

Femi and Seun Kuti, like father like sons

Fแบนlรก’s two sons, Femi and Seun, have inherited and โ€œcarried forwardโ€ their father’s passion for social justice through music.

Femi Kuti, performing at Warszawa Cross Culture Festival. Image by Henryk Kotowski via Wikimedia Commons, 25 September 2011 (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Femi Kuti, Fแบนlรก’s eldest son, is an accomplished Afrobeat musician and saxophonist in his own right. Femi’s songs like โ€œSorry Sorryโ€œ, โ€œWhat Will Tomorrow Bringโ€ and โ€œ’97โ€ โ€” do not spare Nigeria’s corrupt and incompetent rulers. For instance, in โ€œSorry Sorryโ€, Femi laments the hypocritical attempt by the ruling elites, who in secret destroy the nation but pretend at finding solutions in public:

“Politicians and soldiers hold meetings/they want to repair our country/ they behave as though/ they don’t know/ that they are the ones who spoilt our country.”

Femi, a multiple Grammy nominee, is as brash and impatient as his late father. In an interview with Vanguard, a Nigeria newspaper, in February 2011, he decimated Nigeria’s corrupt class: โ€œIt is very evident that things are very bad in our country; politicians keep stealing money, we donโ€™t have good roads, proper education, and potable water and so on. I canโ€™t accept that. The majority of Nigerians are suffering. I donโ€™t accept this and my father showed us a way to complain through music and that is what I am doing.โ€

Seun Kuti at the 2008 Marsatac Festival in Marseille, France. Image by Benoรฎt Derrier via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).

Fแบนlรก’s youngest son, Seun Kuti is a musician and social justice advocate. Seun was an active participant in the 2012 #OccupyNigeria protests against the gas price hikes. He was also involved in the 2020 #EndSARS protests.

Seun has been described as the โ€œPrince of Afrobeats,โ€ in the footsteps of his father, the king of Afrobeat. Toyin Falola, Nigerian historian and professor of African Studies further asserts that: โ€œSeunโ€™s alignment did not start recently. He showed an early interest in music, especially the type of music his father sings, and he started to perform alongside Fela and the Egypt 80 band when he was just nine years old. It would not be out of place to call that a prodigious act.โ€

Nigerian voices against Apartheid in South Africa

Cover of Sonny Okosun’s Vinyl record

Critical music against political leadership was not limited to military dictatorship alone.

Nigerian musicians like Sonny Okosun, Majek Fashek, Onyeka Onwenu โ€” and many others โ€” also protested against apartheid in South Africa, calling for the release of Nelson Mandela.

Sonny Okosun (1947โ€”2008), Nigeriaโ€™s highlife and reggae star, in โ€œPapaโ€™s Landโ€ (1977) and โ€œFire in Sowetoโ€ (1978) condemned the suppression of black South Africans by their apartheid governments.

Following in Okosunโ€™s footsteps was Nigeriaโ€™s guitarist and reggae star, Majek (Majekodunmi) Fashek (1963-2020) dedicated his song โ€œFree Africa, Free Mandelaโ€ to South Africaโ€™s Nelson Mandela, whom he described as a prisoner of conscience.

Onyeka Onwenu (Image credit from Onyeka Onwenu Facebook Fan Club)

However, one of the most endearing and emotional protest renditions against apartheid came from Nigeriaโ€™s singer, actress, and journalist Onyeka Onwenu in her song, โ€œWinnie Mandela.โ€ Onwenu described Winnie Mandela as the โ€œsoul of a nation, fighting to be free!โ€

Onwenu explained that she wrote the song after watching a documentary about the Mandelas, which moved her to tears. She โ€œidentifiedโ€ with Winnieโ€™s โ€œloneliness and some of her pain.โ€ During the sleepless night that followed, the Nigerian musician put her โ€œpain to a songโ€ to โ€œgive something back to Winnie for the sacrifice of her life to the Apartheid struggle,โ€ Onwenu wrote in April 2018.

Other Nigerians who sang against the social injustice of apartheid were Victor Essiet and the Mandators in the song โ€œApartheid.โ€


Banned Songs From Nigeria And Uganda Which Represent The Voices Of The People

These songs challenged governments and oppression alike

โ€œFela Kuti Birthday Tributeโ€ Image by Lucy Anne, October 15, 2010 (CC BY-ND 2.0).

This article was originally published by Global Voices on 21st of March 2022 and is republished here with permission of the authors, Richard Wanjohi and Nwachukwu Egbunike.


A little over 6o years ago, African states gained independence from their colonial masters. It was assumed the wind of change would bring with it a new sense of nationalism, common good, and identity. However many of the heads of state and governments almost immediately broke their promise to promote a different form of governance.

Music has always been integral to Africa’s liberation and freedom struggles. In South Africa, anti-apartheid music faced significant censorship Similarly, in Nigeria, musicians stood in solidarity with South Africans, calling for the release of Nelson Mandela or calling out police brutality, while being the voices of protests. These African musicians felt they could not go on dancing when everything around them was not worth celebrating.

They felt a responsibility to use their voice to speak to the times they were living. In the same vein, many countries found their voices with popular groups and musicians, though initially accepted by the authorities, they ended up being sanctioned and/or banned altogether.

In this two-part series, we go into the history of various musicians around the continent whose music was deemed too political and explore why their music was considered so โ€˜dangerousโ€™ by their governments.

Nigeria

In his lifetime, the late Afrobeat legend, Fแบนlรก Anรญkรบlรกpรฒ Kรบtรฌ witnessed quite a number of sanctions, court cases, police brutality, and a radio ban on his revolutionary music. Despite the state pressure, he never ceased to dish out the melodies that many Nigerians and Africans all over the world relate to.

In the then military era of Nigeria, it was forbidden for any radio station to play Kรบtรฌ’s songs and any citizen seen associating with the revolutionary musician either in person or through his songs was deemed an enemy of the state. Once upon a time, Fแบนlรก’s residence, in Lagos, Nigeria’s commercial capital, known as the Kalakuta Republic was attacked by a thousand soldiers, who committed various wicked acts like raping, stealing, and beating citizens. During the assault, his elderly mother was thrown from a tall building, an incident that led to a broken leg and eventually her death. After that military invasion of his house, Fแบนlรก released โ€œZombieโ€ and โ€œUnknown Soldierโ€ in 1981, both songs, dedicated to the soldiers that invaded his house. 

An artistic representation of Fแบนlรก Anรญkรบlรกpรฒ Kรบtรฌ. Image by Danny PiG uploaded to Flickr on September 11, 2012. (CC BY-SA 2.0)

In 2004, former Nigerian president, Olรบแนฃแบนฬgun แปŒbasanjแปฬ banned the popular themed song of the poverty-stricken nation titled โ€œJร gร -jรกgรก.โ€ In Jร gร -jรกgรก, a song that went viral even outside Nigeria, Eedris Abdulkareem sang in anger, lamenting the state of the suffering of Nigerians and also the social ills that ensued as a means of survival in the face of abject poverty. The controversial album led to the ban of the song on radio and television, it secured him an invitation to the presidential villa (Aso Rock) in the Federal Capital Territory where the president warned him to desist from releasing songs that ridicule the country and place it in a bad light to the outside world. The artist remained obstinate and aired the president’s request in another song titled โ€œLetter to Mr. Presidentโ€ released the following year.  

Uganda

In 2017, Robert Kyagulanyi Ssentamu also known as Bobi Wine while serving as a Member of Parliament in Ugandaโ€™s Parliament released a song titled โ€œFreedom.โ€ Using his platform as a local leader and influence among the urban youth in the country, Bobiโ€™s song sought to address the countryโ€™s challenges of overstaying leaders. He mentioned Ugandaโ€™s Bush War of the 1980s that saw current president Yoweri Museveni oust Milton Obote. He asked why Museveni is practicing what he fought against โ€” comparing the current government to slavery and the tension to South Africaโ€™s apartheid system.

Bobi Wine by Mbowasport is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0 

Bobi also questioned the purpose of the Ugandan constitution which he calls the countryโ€™s last hope. He mentioned the lack of freedom of expression in the country, urging Ugandans to speak up against injustice with freedom being for all โ€” regardless of age, social class, religion, or education.

One of his more popular songs, โ€œGhetto,โ€ talks about police brutality against people residing in the slums of Kampala and the inadequate services delivered to them. In April 2019, Bobi Wine under went house arrest, and during this time, he composed another multilingual song about police brutality entitled โ€œAfande,โ€ a Swahili word for an officer.

Since 2018, some of his songs have been banned from being performed, or even played on-air, as state functionaries believed he would use his music for political and promotional purposes. Shortly thereafter, he declared his interest in running for the country’s presidency in elections that took place in early 2021.

Joining him in the elections circuit was another popular musician Joseph Mayanja also known as Jose Chameleone. His entry into politics by declaring his candidacy for the mayoral position of Kampala, saw his concerts canceled. In 2016, the artist turned politician assaulted a journalist and DJ resulting in his music being banned by Trace TV, a French-based music TV channel that airs music across the globe.

Please see part two of this series here.

Find Global Voice’s Spotify playlist highlighting these and other banned songs from around the world here. For more information about banned music, see our special coverage, Striking the Wrong Notes.